I found Dan Hsu’s blog today. It’s about his experiences as a gaming journalist at EGM. Check out all three parts if you are interested in how advertising and pr folks influence coverage of the industry.
I was inspired to write a smidgen of a blog post about my limited experience with public relations influence over how games are reviewed. VGT is a small fish compared to sites like IGN, Gamespot, and 1up, but our reviews warrant the same critical value on sites like Gamerankings and Metacritic.
In late April, I got an invite to a media event in San Diego for the Bourne Conspiracy game. This entailed a $475 plane ticket, two night stay in the Hard Rock Hotel ($450), transportation to the event / airport and a party hosted by the development team with a open bar that dished out endless mojitos all night.
There were about twelve writers from other “small fish” sites that made the trip as well. I wouldn’t be shocked if Sierra or High Moon Studios dished out $15,000 over the 3 days. We got a brief tour of the studios and shuffled into the a couple rooms to get some hands on time with the game.
After the day trip, we were given some swag and shuffled back on the transport bus. The group was told that we couldn’t report on anything that happened that day until after the game was released. Our entire experience had essentially been embargoed until a point in time when a preview wouldn’t be newsworthy. As I drifted off to sleep in my comfy Hard Rock Hotel king sized bed that night, I pondered what their actual intention was.
They wanted to dilute the overall review average by befriending the press that doesn’t get invited to these events. I ended up giving the game 3.5 out of 5 stars, but the majority of the people at that event scored it 80% or higher. I admit that I actually felt guilty about scoring the game on the lower end and pushed publication of the review for a couple weeks.
I certainly don’t regret going on this press junket. It’s the type of event that the IGN’s of the world frequent constantly. I met a couple cool writers and really appreciated the entertaining weekend trip, despite the plane ride. It was also an enlightening look at how schmoozing can heavily influence the review process. And somewhat disconcerting.
I downloaded the 

